Monday, July 27, 2009

Rating the bantam drafts: 2005

A few weeks back I started what was to be a series of posts looking at the relative success each team has had in the bantam drafts. I started with the 2006 draft but have not gotten around to any more.....until now anyway....

So, the 2005 draft now. These are the 1990's, the players who will be 19 this upcoming season. I've changed the games-played categories a bit since these players have had three full seasons to play in the WHL.

There aren't very many 19 year old rookies at this level, so it's pretty fair to say that any players from this draft who haven't made the WHL already probably aren't going to.


Total PicksUnder 5050 - 100100 - 150150 - 200Over 200Total GPWHLersGP/pickListed %
Brandon112211053554.5%48.654.5%
Calgary110331084663.6%76.954.5%
Everett122321073366.7%61.166.7%
Kamloops100512087580%87.570%
Kelowna80013072850%9162.5%
Kootenay91211048655.6%5433.3%
Lethbridge102021041650%41.630%
Medicine Hat113121049163.6%44.627.3%
Moose Jaw90212068155.6%75.755.6%
Portland142311057250%40.928.6%
Prince Albert121221058950%49.141.7%
Prince George122101022133.3%18.433.3%
Red Deer121250086966.7%72.458.3%
Regina90321187677.8%97.366.7%
Saskatoon114012053863.6%48.927.3%
Seattle101112060950%60.930%
Spokane130111158130.8%44.753.8%
Swift Current112310165463.6%59.527.3%
Tri-City111012050436.4%45.827.3%
Vancouver91023080466.7%89.355.6%

The first eight columns are probably obvious.....explanation of the others:

WHLers: the % of a team's picks who have played at least one game in the WHL
GP/pick: the average number of WHL games played per pick
Listed %: the % of a team's picks who are still listed on a WHL protected list somewhere

Pretty good draft for Regina, Kelowna, Vancouver, Kamloops, Red Deer, Calgary....they all got a good number of contributing WHLers out of this draft. Very, very poor draft for Prince George, who only got one WHLer out of the whole draft - and that was Dale Hunt at #3 overall, and it's clear today that there were a lot better players picked after him too.

Prince George is in a class of their own here, but Lethbridge, Seattle and Portland are other teams that didn't have good 2005 drafts. Lethbridge got few players of substance, while Seattle missed on their first rounder, while Portland did get seven guys who played in the league at some point but only 4 of them are still on protected lists at age 19....and maybe only one of those is an impact player.

Best picks:
- Kelowna, Evan Bloodoff (6th rd, 199 games played)
- Regina, Jordan Eberle (7th rd, 197 games played)
- Vancouver, Craig Cunningham (7th rd, 187 games played)

Worst picks:
- Seattle, Cody Hanson (1st rd, 47 career games played)
- Prince George, Matt Belich (high 2nd rd, 2 career games played)
- Swift Current, Nicholas Navratil (3rd rd, I believe he quit hockey even before the draft)

The draft picks who have played in the league, with their games played totals:

Brandon: Sanfred King (98), Jordan Hale (112), Andrew Hayes (66), Colby Robak (175), Alex Grill-Donovan (48), Andrew Hewett (36)
Calgary: Brendan Rowinski (145), Ian Schultz (126), Michael Stone (195), Martin Jones (97), Devon Kalinski (120), Ryan Fox (95), Taylor Gal (68)
Everett: Kyle Beach (183), Matthew Ius (126), Matt Strong (92), Tyler Skauge (52), Brendon Wall (36), Tyler Hlookoff (126), James Reid (18), Chris De La Lande (100)
Kamloops: Tyler Shattock (176), Jordan Rowley (185), Paul Van De Velde (52), Dalyn Flette (56), Kurt Torbohm (99), Todd Kennedy (69), Mark Hall (99), Shayne Wiebe (139)
Kelowna: Tyler Myers (191), Riley McIntosh (142), Brandon McMillan (196), Evan Bloodoff (199)
Kootenay: Jordan Wilkins (59), Steele Boomer (97), Kevin King (198), Brent Henke (131), Daniel Salamandyk (1)
Lethbridge: Travis Bobbee (173), Bo Montgomery (104), Sterling Bear (2), Colin Frederickson (3), Craig Orfino (134)
Medicine Hat: Jordan Hickmott (157), Shayne Neigum (131), Kurtis Decker (2), Josh Koper (55), Adrian Van de Mosselaer (102), Lee Morrow (20), Colton Graf (24)
Moose Jaw: Neal Prokop (179), Chad Suer (179), Jason Grecica (84), Brian Sommers (99), Travis Hamonic (140)
Portland: Thomas Frazee (173), Ty Ariss (63), Colin Reddin (95), Devon Marshall (44), Tayler Jordan (109), Randy McNaught (81), Brenden Stephen (7)
Prince Albert: Jordan Trach (106), Blaine Tendler (172), James Dobrowolski (139), Kyle Aschim (41), Steven Stanford (73), Mike Small (58)
Prince George: Dale Hunt (158), Matthew Belich (2), Trevor Bauer (58), Joel Danyluk (3)
Red Deer: Cass Mappin (143), Zak Stebner (142), Joel Kot (85), Colin Archer (111), Mike Scarborough (129), Matt Fraser (134), Spencer Edwards (38), Morgan Clark (87)
Regina: Colten Teubert (203), Brayden Metz (72), Jeff Bosch (68), Kyle St. Denis (90), Curtis Kulchar (104), Jordan Eberle (197), Brent Raedeke (142)
Saskatoon: Teigan Zahn (171), Travis Toomey (129), Gaelan Patterson (175), Jared Friesen (3), Kevin Philp (36), Cameron Canart (3), Mike Clements (21)
Seattle: Cody Hanson (47), Jeremy Boyer (199), Jacob DeSerres (65), Sena Acolatse (186), Isak Quakenbush (112)
Spokane: Mitch Wahl (201), Mike Reddington (194), Darcy Kuemper (55), Tyler Johnson (131)
Swift Current: Geordie Wudrick (216), Ian Curtis (40), Phil Gervais (106), Jordan Mistelbacher (96), Eddie Friesen (4), Kris Foucault (62), Clayton Cumiskey (130)
Tri-City: Eric Mestery (172), Tyler Schmidt (179), Kyle Birch (17), David Robinson (136)
Vancouver: James Wright (181), Lance Bouma (173), Nathan Deck (144), Mike Piluso (107), Craig Cunningham (187), Kraymer Barnstable (12)

1 comment:

Unknown said...

Interesting. It might be worth a mention from where in the draft (ignoring trades) each of the teams was picking from...

Good draft:
Regina (1st), Kelowna (19th), Vancouver (9th), Kamloops (6th), Red Deer (12th) and Calgary (13th).

Not quite so good draft:
Prince George (4th), Lethbridge (15th), Seattle (16th) and Portland (11th).